Carrying out tough tasks rarely feels appealing before you start. Yet, once the effort is behind you, the outcome often feels more rewarding than you would have expected. Recent research has shown this effect by asking people to choose between taking a small cash prize or receiving a mug they would need to earn by climbing a few flights of stairs. When that climb was still ahead of them, most chose the money. After they had already done the climbing, many preferred to keep the mug instead.
Scientists call this the “effort paradox.” Hard work tends to feel unpleasant when looking ahead, but rewarding in hindsight because it makes the result feel more valuable. This explains everything from exercise routines to why building your own bookshelf makes you like it more than a fancy pre-built one, and it reveals something surprising about how our minds attach value to hard work.
Why Our Minds Flip the Script After the Fact
Image via Unsplash/Garrhet Sampson
Psychologists have seen this pattern again and again. It’s been called everything from the IKEA effect to cognitive dissonance. In plain terms, people assign more worth to things they’ve worked for, whether or not the work actually improves the result. You could struggle through assembling a wobbly table, curse your way through missing screws, but still be proud of it afterward. Why? Because effort isn’t just a cost. It’s also a cue to your brain that the thing must’ve been worth it.
That reasoning might not make perfect sense logically. Folks will often keep pouring time into projects they’ve already invested in, even when quitting would be more practical. That’s the sunk cost effect. The more you’ve worked for something, the harder it is to walk away from it, because effort rewires your sense of what’s valuable.
Not Everyone Sees Effort the Same Way
There’s no one-size-fits-all rule for how people react to work. Some people always treat effort as a penalty while others treat it as a badge of honor. In between are mixed profiles of folks who like a little challenge but back off when things get overwhelming. There are also those who seem allergic to low-effort tasks and actually prefer when things are hard.
Researchers developed a model to explain these patterns. It basically says our minds constantly weigh the cost of effort against its potential benefits. And those benefits aren’t always about the outcome. Sometimes, effort itself feels good. That can happen during intense focus, like when you're locked into a project or game and lose track of time. It’s called a flow state. In that zone, effort stops feeling like a burden and starts to feel like momentum.
It Isn’t Always About Getting Something
Now this idea flips a lot of old thinking on its head. Traditional economics and decision theories treated effort as a tax on reward. You had to push through work to earn something good. However, more recent studies show that people don’t always think of effort that way. In fact, animals and humans both sometimes pick harder options, even when easier ones offer the same payoff. In one experiment, rats and birds worked for food that they could’ve gotten for free. Researchers call this “contra-freeloading,” choosing to work when it’s not required.
What’s behind that? One theory is that effort brings a sense of control or agency. Another is that it gives context to the reward. When something is earned, not handed over, it feels different. Even young children and non-human animals seem to understand that dynamic.
The Role of Timing and Anticipation
Image via Unsplash/Tyler Harris
Most people devalue tasks that lie ahead. That’s part of why starting anything hard like a fitness routine, a side hustle, or a big work project can feel so miserable. We anticipate the grind and get discouraged before lifting a finger. But once we’ve put in some work, the same task that felt dreadful suddenly feels meaningful. That shift is how our minds track value.
It gets even more interesting when you factor in anticipation. In some situations, people actually look forward to effort, especially when it’s tied to something meaningful, like raising money for a cause. Researchers have found that people give more when the act of donating includes some discomfort or challenge. Running a 5K for charity makes people donate more than attending a fundraising picnic.
Too Much Effort Can Backfire
Of course, there’s a limit. Effort feels good up to a point. Push beyond that, and it starts to wear people down. Some folks can tolerate high levels of exertion, while others reach burnout quickly. The sweet spot is different for everyone. One person’s satisfying challenge is another’s mental wall. That’s why effort-based motivation systems, whether in work, school, or wellness, only succeed when they’re balanced. Too much demand with too little return leads to frustration. Too little effort and people feel bored or detached.
Boredom and effort also have a strange connection. Easy tasks can still feel exhausting when they lack engagement. Staring at spreadsheets or going through dull routines can require lots of mental control just to stay focused. In those cases, people often switch to harder but more stimulating tasks because they want less boredom. So it’s not only the amount of work that matters but also the way that work feels.
Making Peace With Hard Work
Understanding the effort paradox helps explain why people run marathons, build their own furniture, or teach themselves hard skills late in life. It also explains why those same people might moan and drag their feet at the beginning. Our brains discount future work and overvalue past effort. We tend to measure things more favorably once we’ve already paid the price.
This perspective also sheds light on how motivation can shift over time. If early efforts are paired with some form of internal or external reward, people are more likely to stick with tasks and build habits. Over time, the act of trying itself can start to feel worthwhile, even enjoyable. That’s what psychologists call “learned industriousness.” When effort gets tied to success often enough, effort becomes its own kind of reward.