Most Valuable Vintage Board Games Ever Made

Most of us grew up playing board games with our friends and family, and even in the digital age, many of us still do. According to Research and Markets, the market size for board games in 2023 is $12 billion. Games like Red Cathedral and Heat are leading the way, but the oldies like Monopoly still hold places in our hearts.

You may have some of these older board games tucked away and forgotten in an attic or basement, or have come across them in thrift stores. What you may not realize is that quite a few of these old board games can be valuable. Some games can sell for thousands of dollars, especially if they are in good condition, with all of the playing pieces intact. These vintage and antique board games recently sold for top dollar.

Lost in Space 3D Action Fun Game

Maker: Remco

Year made: 1966

Lost in Space 3D Action Fun Game Value

Sold at auction: $340

Bottom Line: Lost in Space 3D Action Fun Game

The Lost in Space 3D Action Fun Game was based on the popular TV science fiction series, "Lost in Space," from the 1960s.

The board has three levels, and players use a spinner to advance around the board.

You can only move to new levels if you land on the right space. 

Haunted House

Maker: Ideal

Year made: 1962

Haunted House Value

Sold at auction: $475

Bottom Line: Haunted House

In the Haunted House game by Ideal, players explore a large, plastic-molded, three-dimensional haunted house, searching for a secret door that conceals a jewel.

The first player to have the jewel and successfully escape from the house wins the game. Players use a spinner that emits an owl’s hoot to move spaces.

The house is full of traps and surprises that can send players back a certain number of spaces, or even back to the start.

Dark Tower

Maker: Milton Bradley

Year made: 1981

Dark Tower Value

Sold at auction: $580

Bottom Line: Dark Tower

Dark Tower is a fantasy quest game in which players must get an ancient magic scepter from an evil king who lives in the Dark Tower.

Players search for three keys that unlock the tower and raise armies to besiege the evil king. All of the players’ moves are fed into a small, battery-operated computer, which keeps track of who is winning.

The Game of Goose

Maker: Spears Games

Year made: 1930s 

The Game of Goose Value

Price: $637

Bottom Line: The Game of Goose

Gioco dell ’Oca (The Game of Goose) is a children’s game that is said to back to Ancient Egypt.

The game, similar to Snakes and Ladders, has players throw dice to move along a spiral track, trying to reach the end, while facing obstacles, such as an inn, a bridge or even death.

Copies of the Italian version of the game from the 1930s are especially valuable.

71 Board Games!

Maker: Whitman Western Publishing Co

Year made: 1969

71 Board Games! Value

Value: $865

Bottom Line: 71 Board Games!_

This vintage game is supposedly 71 different board games all in one. While the details of the gameplay are unclear, what is clear is that it's a very rare find.

One solitary copy of the gambling-themed family game board game was available on eBay for nearly $900. 

Inflation Board Game

Maker: Charles Joseph Carpenter Games

Year made: 1974

Vintage Inflation Board Game Value

Value: $974.95

Bottom Line: Vintage Inflation Board Game

Inflation was one of the first Monoply-esque games invented. It was very popular back when it came out in the mid-1970s, and it's very hard to come by today.

Intended for two to seven players, the game challenges you to trade and sell your way to a million dollars. It's more challenging than Monopoly, but just as fun.

The particular edition comes with all the pieces and very little wear and tear. 

Settlers of Catan 3D Collector’s Edition

Maker: Catan Studio

Year made: 2005

Settlers of Catan 3D Collector’s Edition Value

Sold: $995 

Bottom Line: Settlers of Catan 3D Collector’s Edition

This game, The Settlers of Catan, has a board made up of unusual hexagonal tiles, which can be rearranged each time players start a new game.

Players compete for natural resources, such as lumber, wool, brick or grain, and deal with accidents and incidents. Raiding the resources of other players and building roads, cities and settlements let a player accumulate points. 

While the game involves strategy and planning, the players also create a storyline as they play. The Settlers of Catan won major game awards from 1995 to 2015.

Transogram Jonny Quest Board Game

Maker: Transogram

Year made: 1964

Transogram Jonny Quest Board Game Value

Value: $1,000

Bottom Line: Transogram Jonny Quest Board Game

Another intriguing game from the 1960s is the original 1964 Jonny Quest board game. For those who don't know, "Jonny Quest" was an animated sci-fi/adventure series produced by ABC that followed a boy named Jonny who joined his dad, a scientist, on wild adventures. The franchise also spawned two television films and three video games.

This board game was missing a few pieces, but it's still one of the most valuable on the market. 

Keywood

Maker: R&D Games

Year made: 1995 

Keywood Value

Sold: $1,200

Bottom Line: Keywood

Keywood is a settlers game in which two to five players try to settle and control six villages. Each player must start as a farmer and then buy trade licenses, which allow them to become traders.

In addition, each village must select leaders who make decisions about taxes, trade licenses and markets. As each village is able to open a new market, its income doubles. Between earning income and paying taxes, players accumulate money. The player with the most money at the end of the game wins.

Only 200 copies of this game were made.

Fortune

Maker: Parker Brothers

Year made: 1935 

Fortune Value

Sold at auction: $1,360

Bottom Line: Fortune

The game Fortune was released by Parker Brothers in 1935 and was similar to Monopoly. Fortune was based on New York City’s streets, however. 

Only about 5,000 of the games were made, as Parker Brothers bought the rights to Monopoly shortly after releasing Fortune. At that point, they changed the game's name to Finance and Fortune and discontinued it.

Im Wintersportparadies Board Game

Maker: Ravensburg

Year made: 1934

Im Wintersportparadies Board Game Value

Value: $1,450

Bottom Line: Im Wintersportparadies Board Game

If you've never heard of Im Wintersportparadies, we don't blame you. It was published in 1934 by Otto Maier Verlag Ravensburg and designed and written by Walter Kahnert and Hubert Mumelter. The artwork is impressive to look at, but the game is written in German.

The exact rules need a formal translation, but the gist of it is as follows: The players move their piece by rolling the dice and traveling along a wintery path on the board. They can take part in up to four competitions, winning or losing money based on the outcome. Anyone who runs out of money is eliminated, and the last player remaining wins. Alternatively, if more than one player reaches the finish line, the one who has the most money wins. 

The version up for sale likely has missing pieces, but it remains a fantastic addition for serious valuable board game collectors. 

The Elvis Presley Game

Maker: Teen-Age Games, Inc.

Year made: 1956 

The Elvis Presley Game Value

Sold at auction: $1,500

Bottom Line: The Elvis Presley Game

Made in 1956, The Elvis Presley Game is a tribute to Elvis Presley and his music. The board is divided into a blue half (for boys) and a pink half (for girls).

The game contains 110 question cards about Elvis’ life and songs. Players use a spinner to select a card and can only move on the board if they answer the question correctly. If they don’t know the right answer, the player is penalized and moves backward.

Very few copies of this game survive in good condition.

Be a Manager

Maker: Bamco

Year made: 1967 

Be a Manager Value

Sold at auction: $1,500

Bottom Line: Be a Manager

A baseball board game from 1967, the game contains a deck of 120 batter cards and 80 pitcher cards, a cardboard playing field, dice chart, and a hit and run chart.

A complete game in good condition, with all the pieces, sold for top dollar on eBay.

War of the Ring Collector’s Edition

Maker: Nexus Editrice, Fantasy Flight Games, Phalanx Games Deutschland

Year made: 2010

War of the Ring Collector’s Edition Value

Sold at auction: $2,400

Bottom Line: War of the Ring Collector’s Edition

The War of the Ring is a dice-play, strategic fantasy war game, based on "The Lord of the Rings" books.

One player operates the Free Peoples and the other controls the Shadow Armies. The Free Peoples player must complete the Ringbearer Quest and reach Mt. Doom to destroy the One True Ring to win. The player with the Shadow Armies must conquer the Free Peoples to win. 

While regular editions of this game can be worth hundreds of dollars, the collector’s edition released on the 10th anniversary of the game’s launch was especially valuable.

Coromandel Games Compendium

Maker Betjemann and Sons Makers London

Year made: Circa 1860

Coromandel Games Compendium Value

Sale price: $2,411.78

Bottom Line: Coromandel Games Compendium

The Compendium is a collection of various games: chess, checkers, backgammon, dominoes, playing cards and more. Both the pieces and the boards for each game are housed together in a wooden box with lift-out trays.

These sets were made around the 1860s from Coromandel wood, a brown wood with black stripes, which has since been logged to extinction.

Munsters Masquerade Party Vintage Board Game

Maker: Hasbro

Year made: 1964

Munsters Masquerade Party Board Game Value

Value: $2,499.99

Bottom Line: Munsters Masquerade Party Vintage Board Game

Remember "The Munsters"? The campy '60s TV show was a hit back in the day, and this extremely rare game was, too. Intended for children, this game is based on the traditional roll and move format and is similar to Candy Land. Players can lose turns or be sent back a few spaces when they land on certain spots.

Land on a "Pick a Party Card," and you'll have to draw a card, read it out loud and immediately follow the instructions. This usually involves silliness of some sort, like singing or making animal noises. Any player who refuses forfeits their next three turns. The first player to the finish line wins.

This particular edition was hand-signed by Butch Patrick, who played Eddie Munster.

Monopoly (French Edition)

Maker: Miro Company — Paris

Year made: 1957

Monopoly (French Edition) Value

Value: $2,546

Bottom Line: Monopoly (French Edition)

Parker Brothers released a French edition of Monopoly for the French market through the Miro Company.

This version of the classic game used francs and Parisian locations in place of the standard Atlantic City locales and American dollars. It's a good time in any language.

Swift Meats Major League Baseball Game

Maker: Swift Meats

Year made: 1957 

Swift Meats Major League Baseball Game Value

Sold at auction: $2,644

Bottom Line: Swift Meats Major League Baseball Game

Swift Meats issued a baseball game in 1957 that is extremely rare today, especially in good condition.

The game consists of 18 cards of real-life baseball players, including diamond legends Hank Aaron and Frank Robinson. The cards are printed in color, with perforations, and each card is meant to be punched out and used to assemble 3D figures of the players.

A paper board game is then used to play a game with the assembled figures.

Fox and Geese

 Maker: McLoughlin Brothers

Year made: 1830 

Fox and Geese Value

Value: $17,827

Bottom Line: Fox and Geese

Fox and Geese is an old hunting game that dates back to the Middle Ages, or even earlier. It’s played on a cross-shaped board using pegs or marbles.

The single fox attempts to "kill" the geese by removing them from the board, while the geese attempt to trap the fox so he can’t move.

An English version of the game dating from 1830 is scarce and valuable.

Monopoly Atlantic City

Maker: Charles Darrow

Year made: 1933 

Monopoly Atlantic City Value

Sold at auction: $146,500

Bottom Line: Monopoly Atlantic City

Monopoly Atlantic City is the original game created by Charles Darrow. Loosely based on another popular game called "The Landlord Game," the board was modeled on the actual streets and real houses around Darrow’s house in Atlantic City, New Jersey. 

Only 5,000 copies of the original game were made, and only a few are known to survive. In 1935, Parker Brothers bought the game from Darrow and made it famous.

You’ll recognize Darrow’s distinctive early version if you happen to stumble across one in a thrift store or garage sale, as the board is circular.

Related: Best Toys of All Time